Earliest First-hand Field Photos on iNaturalist?

I was taking a look again at the earliest images that I've scanned and uploaded to iNaturalist. Those date from the late 1960s (see below). There are now thousands of earlier images of organisms on iNaturalist but the majority of them are images of museum specimens of plants, insects, mollusks, etc. So I began looking for the earliest images of organisms in the field, so to speak, using the simple filters on the Explore page.

I quickly had to qualify my search of old observations on iNaturalist. First, I summarily ruled out those museum specimens, and since I wouldn't expect to see photographic field evidence prior to 1900, I started my search at the beginning of the 20th Century. I also disregarded the unfortunate set of modern observations with erroneous observation dates (evident from high quality digital images dated to the 1900's, etc.).

I began to uncover a number of "observations" from secondary sources like images out of newspapers of beached whales, captured sharks, etc., and photos from published research papers. Those certainly provide "evidence" of an organism, but the dates are sometimes estimated or very approximate and the original "observer", i.e. the photographer, is rarely stated. These include such examples as a Pel's Pouched Bat from Niangara, Congo, presumably a captured specimen and dated May 27, 1913, documented in a Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History, and uploaded in 2014 by @jakob :

So I began combing through observations chronologically, looking for the earliest first-hand personal evidence of living or recently dead animals or plants.

There is a photo of a public gathering around a Great White Shark, presumably captured off the coast of Turkey in 1920, and uploaded in 2021 by @gorkialkan.

The earliest image of any animal which is not a captured or museum specimen seems to be the following beached Rorqual (Baleen whale) in Tampico, Mexico, dated February 4, 1922. @josecastaneda2 uploaded the image, stating that it is from the digital Historical Archives of Tampico.

The earliest first-person, non-photographic account of an organism seems to be W. C. Russell's notes on Yellow-bellied Marmots ("woodchucks") in Elko Co., Nevada, recorded in his field journal for July 13, 1935, and uploaded by @floydch in 2019:

And--drum roll, please--the earliest first-hand, field photo on iNaturalist of a living organism seems to be this Koala documented in Victoria, Australia on December 31, 1935. https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/77862210
I've left a message for @nimzee, who uploaded the image in 2021, for more details on the photographer, etc. It does not appear to be a commercial or secondary source image, so I'll look forward to learning more about its provenance.

The earliest observations of any plant uploaded to iNaturalist are apparently some European Larch trees in the background of a set of family ski vacation images in the French Alps, taken by L. Hunault in January 1936, and uploaded in 2021 by @mercantour.

It gets a little difficult when trying to pin down the earliest first-hand, first-person photos of an organism, since it isn't often clearly stated that the iNaturalist/uploader was the person who took the image. But there are some likely candidates.
In 2020, @hoaryherper uploaded a couple of herp pics from his childhood. The earliest is one he took of a Blue Racer grabbed by his friend John Evans on June 20, 1949 in Ohio:
@hoaryherper also uploaded an image of himself (taken by John Evans) with a captured Prairie Kingsnake in Pennington Co., South Dakota from June 21, 1955:

@americanisopodologist uploaded a couple pictures of recently-caught fish at Chincoteague, Virginia in June 1955. These are akin to the above documentation of a Great White Shark but these are family photos, in the first instance taken by his grandfather:
Red Drum: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/106281440
Billfishes: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/106281439

My late pal Greg Lasley got minimal documentation with his dad's Bell and Howell movie camera of an Eastern Cottontail in Shillington, Pennsylvania, on/about September 19, 1962, during a family trip:
And just 10 days later, about Septermber 29, 1962, found himself with his family in La Rochelle, France, using the same camera to document a Gray Heron:

My earliest iNat observation is a shell I'd collected in about 1958 at a beach near my boyhood home in Southern California, but just recently photographed and uploaded:
My own earliest first-hand field image dates from May 1969, a butterfly photographed in Taiwan with my first new SLR camera, a trusty Minolta SRT-101:

So I offer a challenge for anyone to mine the iNaturalist database of images to find earlier personal, first-hand, field observations. What can you find?

由使用者 gcwarbler gcwarbler2022年05月04日 22:05 所貼文


My earliest is this Black Rhino footprint https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/107750070 taken by my father in 1960, while I was present as a young boy, in the Mana Pools NP, Zimbabwe. I remember it well because I was told that rhinos have 3 toes and the similar hippo has 4 toes by our companion and experienced bushman, Joe Hamling . [I now know that they are in different orders Perissodactyla (=odd-toed) and Artiodactyla (=even-toed)].

發佈由 nyoni-pete 約 2 年 前

Interesting project. Since I'm on the younger side, my earliest observation is from the rather recent year of 2006. I may take a look through some old family photos to see if I can find anything suitable. I know my great-grandfather and some members of that branch of my family were avid naturalists. Establishing where and when such photos were taken may be quite difficult however.

發佈由 alexbinck 約 2 年 前

This is very interesting, thanks for sharing!

發佈由 dinofelis 約 2 年 前

Cool idea, Chuck. I'll have to go back and upload an early fishing success as my personal first and earliest observation: a silver salmon that I caught with my late uncle in his favorite fishing hole. I really enjoy how this exercise almost inherently connects the observation to the personal context and memory of the observer.

發佈由 muir 約 2 年 前

Yes, Diana, those are useful and interesting links, but they don't focus in on the particular subset of observations I wanted to find, that is, first-hand, first-person field images. It's great to now have the thousands of images of museum specimens cross-referenced to iNaturalist, and the old newspaper accounts and other published second-hand reports are also interesting. My search was for more personalized records. To date, I think the 1935 Koala in Australia (link above) comes the closest. I'm still waiting on confirmation that it was a first-hand photo taken by someone (presumably a photographer who is no longer with us) and not from a published source.

發佈由 gcwarbler 約 2 年 前

Perhaps if you link to this journal post on both of those threads you will get a response that fits your question. The interested target audience who have a resource of old photos to work from.

發佈由 dianastuder 約 2 年 前

Diana, Both of the Forum topics you link to have been closed for some time. How do I add a comment to a closed Forum topic?

發佈由 gcwarbler 約 2 年 前

You need to ask a moderator to reopen it for you.
tiwane or bouteloa or ?

發佈由 dianastuder 約 2 年 前

That's right, as I said before, those photos of the beached whale on the beach of Miramar (Tampico), the originals are from the city's chronicler, and I took them from the digitalized photo library of the Historical Archive of Tampico. My job is to try to document the fauna and flora of the region from the past to the present.

發佈由 josecastaneda2 約 2 年 前


登入註冊 添加評論